All That Remains will deploy “A War You Cannot Win” on Tuesday,
Nov. 6, a likely non-coincidental Election Day missive.
Throughout “A War You Cannot Win,” singer Phil Labonte
sounds pissed off about both encroachments on his freedom and the general public's apathy
toward those infringements. “Take back
your freedom,” he rasps on “Sing for Liberty”;
“I won’t follow commands. I won’t meet your demands,” he declares on the title
track.
But “A War You Cannot Win” is not just a political album. In
a quickly paced 40-minute record, All That Remains touches on personal
relationships, philosophical musings, and broadly stated rants and chants. And
there are plenty of stylistic leaps to meet the variety of topics.
If anything, Springfield-bred All That Remains has developed
into metal’s mutt that can kick the ass of purebreds. Labonte handles the death growls and crooned
clean vocals, typically bringing them together in tunes. Lead guitar player
Oli Herbert provides the glue holding together a batch of songs that runs from the commercially
slick hard rock of “What If I Was Nothing” (which sounds like it fell off of a
Staind record) to the bile-splattered thrash of “You Can’t Fill My Shadow.”
Herbert and Labonte are the quintet’s remaining original
members. Neither the guitarist nor the singer performs like he
is satisfied taking All That Remains down one particular road, so they manage to lead All That Remaions all over the place and still hold together the group's identity. The band’s original
metalcore blueprint was way too sparse for Herbert’s guitar style, which takes in
the grandeur of power metal and explosiveness of modern metal. Likewise, Labonte
is too charismatic to just hunker down in a metal bunker mentality and be on
constant attack mode.
Drummer Jason Costa, singer Phil Labonte, guitarist Oli Herbert, bassist Jeanne Sagan, and guitarist Mike Martin |
It’s good hearing a band take risks, and here it’s clear
that All That Remains can alienate the metal fans with songs that are too clean
and smooth as well as shove away the more mainstream rock fans with songs that evolve
into spastic displays of jarring vocals and punishing rhythm work. Some may argue that “A War You Cannot Win”
bows to commercial tastes, but if that were the case it would not nearly be as
diverse as it is. Rather, this is a band ignoring expectations, and doesn’t
topple for it.
There’s little chance that every song will appeal to every
listener_ I can do without the “don’t worry baby, it’ll be all right” shit_ but
All That Remains doesn’t linger on any one point for very long, and at the very
least you can appreciate the raw talent at work in the band.
All That Remains will be playing Sunday, Nov. 4 at the Palladium
in Worcester, MA. Metalocalypse’s Dethklok headlines and
Machine Head is also on the bill. Show time is 7 P.M.